FCC chairman Tom Wheeler says he does not think the FCC has the authority to start shutting down websites used to promote terrorism like that in Paris, but he says there might be some things the FCC could or should do in the face of social media use as a tool to promote violence. He even pledged to use his bully pulpit powers to call Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg to talk about the issue.
During a House Communications Subcommittee FCC oversight hearing, Rep. Joe Barton (R-Texas), who has issues with how the FCC is treating low-power TVs in the incentive auction, decided to seek written responses and instead use his time to talk about the Paris terrorist attacks.
Barton said he was going off script. He said that ISIS and terrorists can't beat the U.S. militarily, but are trying to use the Internet and social media "to beat us psychologically."
Given that, he said, "isn't there something we can do under existing law to shut those Internet sites down." He said that even in an open society, when there was a clear threat, "we could do something about the Internet and social media side of the equation."
Wheeler said he was "not sure our authority extends to picking and choosing among Web sites." But he did say there were specific things the government could do.
Barton asked whether Congress should give it authority to shut down the sites, Wheeler said one issue was the question of what was a "lawful intercept," which is something he said the Congress can define, essentially updating the definition in the Communications Assistance for Law Enforcement Act (CALEA) wiretap law, which was passed in 1994.
"You read in the press that they were using PlayStation 4 games to communicate, which is outside the scope of anything ever considered in CALEA." He said updating the lawful intercept concept might be one thing.
But he also said there was an issue of network security. He cited 17 "mysterious" cuts of fiber links in the Bay Area in the last few months. "We need to have some kind of a 'big data' capability of determining what's happening to our network out there," he said, because it is not only people on the networks, but "perhaps" people doing things to the network.
He said the FCC has the only network outage reporting system in the country, and it is "barely holding together with bailing wire and glue" because it uses "ancient" technology. He pointed out he has been asking for appropriations to update it.
"We have the ability inside our systems to use big data to connect the dots," he said, "but we don’t have the capacity to do it."
Wheeler pledged to work with the committee to update the laws.
Rep. Anna Eshoo (D-Calif.) said that the FBI was dealing with the House Select Committee on Intelligence relative to the Bay Area cuts.
Barton and Eshoo agreed that the network threats were a clear and present danger, and Eshoo said she did not think the cuts of the fiber were a coincidence. Barton said terrorists were using the Internet in an "offensive, inappropriate"—Eshoo added "effective"—way and at minimum the government should make it more difficult, and perhaps "absolutely shut it down."
Rep. Bobby Rush (D-Ill.) talked about violence in Chicago and said it was well known that gang leaders are using social media to advance their violent agendas and conflicts.
He said he understood the FCC had limited jurisdiction over Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, but asked if there was anything the FCC could do in the interests of public safety to curtail the violence. He asked if the FCC would add its voice and stature to the discussion.
Wheeler said the issue was similar to terrorist using social media. "We do not have jurisdiction over Facebook and other edge providers, and we do not intend to assert jurisdiction over them, and I don't believe, as legitimate as your concern is, I don't believe we have the jurisdiction to do the kind of thing that you suggest."
But Wheeler did say he was happy to use his "bully pulpit" to talk to Zuckerberg and others to make the point that this is an important issue that we need to address together, but that the FCC did not have regulatory authority.
Rush said he was not asking for regulation. "I will call Mark Zuckerberg this afternoon to raise the issues you've raised and the issue that Mr. Barton has raised," said Wheeler, "and I'm sure he [Zuckerberg] is concerned about this as well and has some thoughts."