Syndication Ratings: WB Scores May Sweeps Trifecta
All three of Warner Bros.’ rookie shows -- TMZ, Two and a Half Men and George Lopez -- finished their freshman seasons strong, while Warner veteran Ellen DeGeneres, now ending its fourth season, completed a solid year. Most other syndies were sharply down at the conclusion of this year’s May sweeps.
Access magazine TMZ gained 10% since its September premiere, jumping to a 2.2 Nielsen Media Research live-plus-same-day household-ratings average during May sweeps, which ended May 21. TMZ, which airs on Fox stations in big markets, appeared to get a boost from Fox’s high-rated American Idol finale, averaging a 2.6 rating on the night rocker David Cook was named this year’s American Idol.
Charlie Sheen-starrer Two and a Half Men, which was upgraded to access time periods in many markets throughout the year, improved a whopping 70% to a 5.1 average since its September debut.
And Warner Bros.’ other newcomer, George Lopez, jumped 41% since September to a 3.1 and fifth place overall among off-network sitcoms.
Ellen, in fourth place among talk shows, arguably had the genre’s best performance, only losing 5% from last May to a 2.1. That makes Ellen the only talker to only decline by single-digits. Ellen also had its best ratings since mid-March in the sweep’s final week, hitting a 2.3, up 10% both for the week and for the year.
Warner Bros. wasn’t the only syndicator with some good stories to tell. CBS’ Judge Judy finished out a stellar year with its strongest May sweep since 2005, improving 7% from last May to a 4.8 live-plus-same-day average household rating for the sweep. In addition, Judy’s 7.3 GAA ratings average -- in which all viewings of a show’s runs are counted versus the AA rating, which only counts one viewing no matter how many episodes were watched -- was the highest of any show in syndication.
Wheel of Fortune, typically syndication’s highest-rated show, came in second at a 7.1 AA rating. (Wheel does not use GAA ratings because the show is not double-run, while Judy is double-run in most markets.)
The only other first-run strip to show year-to-year growth in May was CBS’ Jeopardy!, which climbed 3% to a 6.0 and third place overall.
Warner’s rookies weren’t the only ones to grow throughout the year. Twentieth Television’s off-net offering, Family Guy, improved 20% since its September debut to a 4.2. Among the daytime newcomers, Twentieth’s The Morning Show with Mike and Juliet jumped 25% from its debut to a 1.0, while NBC Universal’s freshman talker, The Steve Wilkos Show, grew 11% since September to average a 1.0.
Meanwhile, Sony’s Judge David Young was flat at a 0.8. Program Partners’ Merv Griffin’s Crosswords was down 13% to a 0.7. Twentieth’s Temptation lost 20% from its premiere week to a 0.4. Radar Entertainment’s Jury Duty was up 50% to a 0.3 from an opening-week 0.2. And Acme’s The Daily Buzz, which debuted nationally in July 2007, fell 50% from a 0.2 to a 0.1.
Talk, a category in which 10 shows are in development for 2009, was the most challenged genre, with no shows seeing year-to-year increases.
The long-standing talk leader, CBS’ The Oprah Winfrey Show, dropped 11% from last May to a 5.5. CBS’ Dr. Phil fell 15% from last May, although the show could boast about an average gain of 48% over its lead-ins in the metered markets. Disney-ABC’s Live with Regis and Kelly sank 21% to a 2.6.
NBCU’s Maury lost 14% to a 1.9. CBS’ Rachael Ray dropped 10%, the category’s second-smallest decline, to a 1.8. Rachael Ray also notched a strong first place in its time period on WABC in top-market New York, beating her nearest competitors by more than 70%.
CBS’ Montel Williams, in its final May sweep in first run, fell 19% to a 1.3. NBCU’s Jerry Springer had talk’s biggest decline, losing 31% to a 1.1. Warner Bros.’ Tyra Banks, also at a 1.1, was down 15% from last year, although the show saw increases among Tyra’s key demographics. In markets monitored by Local People Meters, Tyra gained 17% among women 18-34 and 20% among women 18-49. NBCU’s Martha Stewart averaged a 0.9, down 25%, although it was up sharply from last May in key markets such as Los Angeles, where the show grew 17%, and Chicago, where it was up 150%.
Without any big celebrity stories breaking in May, all of the access magazines were down by double-digits. CBS’ Entertainment Tonight won its 71st consecutive sweeps with a 4.3, down 14%. In second place, CBS’ Inside Edition lost 12% to a 3.0. At a 2.2, TMZ edged out CBS’ The Insider and NBCU’s Access Hollywood, each of which was down 16% to a 2.1. Warner Bros.’ Extra fell 14% to a 1.8.
Judge Judy was court’s best story, while the rest of the genre was down. CBS’ Judge Joe Brown, in second place, had the second-best May sweep showing, dropping only 4% -- or one-tenth of a ratings point -- to a 2.6. Warner Bros.’ People’s Court slipped 8% to a 2.3. Warner Bros.’ Judge Mathis dropped 17% to a 1.9. Twentieth’s Divorce Court fell 15% to a 1.7. Twentieth’s Judge Alex, also at a 1.7, dipped 6%. Twentieth’s Cristina’s Court and Sony’s Judge Hatchett each fell 21% to a 1.1. Sony’s Judge Maria Lopez declined 11% to a 0.8.
Game shows were the steadiest genre. Leader Wheel of Fortune dipped 3% to a 7.1, followed by Jeopardy! at a 6.0. Disney-ABC’s Who Wants to Be a Millionaire fell 7% to a 2.8, while Debmar-Mercury’s Family Feud was unchanged at a 1.7.
Rookies Two and a Half Men and Family Guy led the off-net sitcoms. In third place, Sony veteran Seinfeld slipped 10% to a 3.8, followed by CBS’ Everybody Loves Raymond, which plunged 27% to a 3.3. Newcomer George Lopez took fifth place, and it was followed by veterans King of Queens at a 2.8, down 10%, and Warner Bros.’ Friends at a 2.6, down 21%.
Broadcasting & Cable Newsletter
The smarter way to stay on top of broadcasting and cable industry. Sign up below
Contributing editor Paige Albiniak has been covering the business of television for more than 25 years. She is a longtime contributor to Next TV, Broadcasting + Cable and Multichannel News. She concurrently serves as editorial director for The Global Entertainment Marketing Academy of Arts & Sciences (G.E.M.A.). She has written for such publications as TVNewsCheck, The New York Post, Variety, CBS Watch and more. Albiniak was B+C’s Los Angeles bureau chief from September 2002 to 2004, and an associate editor covering Congress and lobbying for the magazine in Washington, D.C., from January 1997 - September 2002.