NCTA To FCC: No Way To Third Way

Cable ops tell FCC to leave broadband access where it is

Cable operators represented by the National Cable & Telecommunications Association told the FCC that it has no legal authority to classify any part of broadband Internet access service as a common carrier.

That came in comments at the FCC on Chairman Julius Genachowski's proposed "third way," in which the FCC would reclassify the transmission element of broadband under some Title II common carrier regs.

NCTA said trying to reclassify the service, which a prior FCC concluded should be regulated under the lighter-touch Title I information service classification, was "fundamentally at odds" with the nature of the Internet."

As it has said before, NCTA argues that the "third way" would be a sure way to discourage investment.

"Any ambiguities in the Commission's authority should be addressed by Congress rather than through an effort to impose legacy common carrier regulation on broadband," said NCTA.

NCTA President Kyle McSlarrow has been one of the principal figures in meetings with FCC Chief of Staff Edward Lazarus about possible legislative solutions. But so has Markham Erickson of the Open Internet Coalition, which in its own comments said that the FCC needed to quickly adopt the "third way" approach to clarify its Internet oversight authority.


NCTA To FCC: First, do No Harm

The National Cable & Telecommunications Association says the FCC should adopt a sort of Hippocratic oath for broadband--above all, do no harm--and that applying common carrier regs to Internet access would definitely violate it.

AT&T: FCC's 'Third Way' Would Be Road To Ruin

Company tells commission that its proposal to reclassify broadband transmissions as a telecommunications service subject to some Title II common carrier regs--FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski's so-called "third way" proposal" would be a "road to ruin" based on "incontrovertible" evidence in the public record.

ACA to FCC: Third Way Would Be big Burden

The American Cable Association says that reclassifying broadband as a Title II service will have immediate and significant economic impact on the small and mid-sized cable/telecom companies it represents.