Spectrum Fight: Mom Vs. Apple Pie
Broadcasters face tough lobby against FCC’s ‘national’ repurposing of spectrum
By John Eggerton -- Broadcasting & Cable, 8/22/2011 12:01:00 AM
So far, the work has not earned rave reviews from inside the commission, at least informally.
Not long after the site re-launched, more than one staffer suggested there needed to be a spotlight on the fact that it was tougher to find some information, including newly released decisions and announcements that now required a bit more drilling down into the site.
As one FCC staffer put it this month: “The best feature on the new Website is the link to the previous fcc.gov.” Ouch. But that was seconded by a high official, who said that the agency planned to make the old site their new home page, and actually had to be guided by a reporter to a piece of information regarding their own area of expertise. That second opinion was “thirded” by yet another: “The only button I use on the new site is very user-friendly and instantly directs me to the previous fcc.gov.” That made the polled opinion unanimous, sounding more like a chorus than three solos.
A spokesman for FCC Chairman Julius Genachowski had no comment. —JE
The fact that the auctions are tied to raising money for a first-responder broadband network called for by the 9/11 commission sums up the lobbying challenge of broadcasters, who frankly face a broadband juggernaut of “national purposes,” as well as a Consumer Electronics Association campaign portraying them as squatters and dinosaurs.
They dodged a bullet earlier this month when one of those broadcast protection-lite bills was removed from the debt-ceiling bill. But there will still be a push in early September by Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D-W.Va.), who has vowed to get a bill to the president by Sept. 11.
“This is the toughest challenge ever faced by broadcasters,” says one veteran broadcast attorney. “It is like choosing between Mom [broadcasting] and Apple Pie [all those ‘national purposes’],” said a broadcast lobbyist speaking not for attribution.
Here are some of the forces massed, not against broadcasting necessarily, but for more spectrum, and thus giving the FCC and Congress more cover for actions that could leave broadcasters in a tenuous position.
9/11: Part of the spectrum incentive auction proceeds will go toward paying for and maintaining a broadband emergency communications network. With the 10th anniversary of the tragedy coming up and its memories of firefighters unable to communicate with responders, broadcasters face the kind of passion that Rockefeller has shown for the issue. Rockefeller and Sen. Chuck Schumer (DN. Y.) have enlisted the aid of John Feal, the outspoken 9/11 responder advocate who helped push through a healthcare bill to help victims of rescue/recovery-related illnesses. At a press conference unveiling Feal as their new “pusher,” the pair also included a New York dispatcher who spoke of his frustration on 9/11 as he received calls for help he could not answer because communications were hit and miss at best.
Healthcare: Remote healthcare monitoring has been one of the FCC’s mantras. But it also has the advantage, at least for those promoting it, of potentially saving on healthcare costs, making it a fiscal reform conservatives like. Last month, the conservative think tank Institute for Policy Innovation moderated an event where an AT&T Healthcare Technologies exec and Anand K. Iyer, WellDoc president, talked about the “dwindling” supply of spectrum and the “innovative ways wireless connectivity is changing the face of health care and the spectrum challenges that could kill real healthcare reform in its tracks.”
Jobs, Jobs and More Jobs: Mobile Future released a study at the beginning of this month asserting that “reassigning” spectrum to mobile broadband would create up to 500,000 jobs.
Add in energy monitoring and distance learning, and the fact that without ubiquitous broadband, discounts for online government transactions—renewing licenses, paying taxes— becomes a regressive tax on those without sufficient access and funds, and the momentum to roll over broadcasters on the way to that broadband future gets more difficult to counter.
E-mail comments to email@example.com and follow him on Twitter: @eggerton
No related content found.
No Top Articles
Digital Rapids provides market-leading software and hardware solutions, technology and expertise for transforming live and on-demand video to reach wider audiences on the latest viewing platforms more efficiently, more effectively and more profitably. Empowering applications from..more